Mario, Gunde, Peters, Rhoden & Kelley, llc

— Attorneys and Counselors at Law —

Call Now: (321) 631-0506
Navigation
  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Kenneth E. RhodenKenneth E. Rhoden – Mr. Rhoden has been an attorney practicing in Brevard County since 1986. He has litigated many serious cases including complex divorces and death penalty cases.
    • Michael J. KelleyMichael J. Kelley – Mr. Kelley is an experienced trial attorney with a strong emphasis on Criminal Defense such as DUI, misdemeanors, felonies, VOP, and juvenile cases.
    • Barbara Helm PetersBarbara Helm Peters – Ms. Peters is an experienced trial attorney with an emphasis in Family Law and Criminal Defense. Admitted to the Florida Bar in 1995, she is also a Florida Supreme Court Certified Mediator.  
    • Bonnie Klein RhodenBonnie Klein Rhoden – Ms. Bonnie Rhoden a member of the Florida Bar, practicing elder law, estate planning, incapacity planning, family law, and landlord/tenant law.
    • Emily A OgdenEmily A. Ogden, Esq. – Ms. Ogden works in all areas of Family Law, including Alimony, Child Custody and Support, Paternity, & Adoption. She also handles financial cases such as Bankruptcy and Mortgage Modifications.
    • Christina Farley Long Esq.Christina Farley Long – Ms. Farley is licensed in numerous Federal Courts in Florida and practices in numerous civil law areas, such as Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Insurance Defense and Foreclosure.
    • Kelly Damerow, Esq.Kelly Damerow, Esq. – Mrs. Damerow is a professional and passionate advocate. She provides a wide range of family law services including divorce child support, alimony, modification, paternity, and domestic violence injunctions.
    • Michel WatsonMichel Watson, Esq. – Ms. Watson is an experienced and detail-oriented attorney. She primarily practices in the areas of family law, debt collection, real estate, dependency, and injunctions.
    • Nikie PopovichNikie Popovich, Esq – Nikie Popovich, Esquire works primarily in the areas of appellate law serving all of Florida and especially central Florida.
    • George A. BoorasGeorge A. Booras, Esq – Mr. Boras is an experienced attorney handling several types of cases, from Real Estate and Foreclosures, to Family Law, and Civil Litigation.
    • David Anton GundeDavid Anton Gunde – Mr. Gunde received his Juris Doctorate from the University of Florida in 1987, and admission to the Florida Bar in 1988. He practices Family Law, Civil Litigation, and Criminal Defense.
    • Anthony P. MarioAnthony P. Mario – Mr. Mario founded our firm in Brevard County in 1976. He is retired and is of counsel to the firm. He focused on Family Law, Criminal Defense, and complex Civil Litigation.
  • Practice Areas
    • Family Law
      • Divorce
      • Alimony
      • Paternity
      • Child Custody and Timesharing
      • Grandparent Visitation
      • Adoptions
      • Child Support
      • Injunctions
      • Dependency
      • Prenuptial Agreements
    • Criminal Law
      • Felonies
      • Misdemeanors
      • DUI
      • Juvenile
      • Sexual Crimes
      • Probation & Community Control
      • Appeals
    • Personal Injury
      • Auto Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Dog Bites
      • Slip & Fall
      • Wrongful Death
      • Medical Malpractice
    • Bankruptcy
      • Chapter 7
      • Chapter 13
      • Alternatives to Bankruptcy
    • Foreclosure
      • Foreclosure Defense
      • Foreclosure Alternatives
    • Wills & Probate
      • Last Will
      • Trust vs. Last Will
      • Living Will
      • Health Care Surrogate
      • Power of Attorney
      • Guardianship
      • Probate
  • News & Info
  • Contact Us
      • Attorneys available by phone 24/7
      • Cocoa — Main Office

        (321) 631-0506
        Fax: (321) 690-0119
        319 Riveredge Boulevard
        Cocoa, FL 32922


        Get Directions

      • Melbourne

        (321) 676-2150
        Fax: (321) 690-0119
        1735 West Hibiscus Boulevard #302
        Melbourne, FL 32901


        Get Directions

      • Email Us



    Home » Criminal Law » Criminal Charges, Guilty Defendant, But a Surprising Result

    Criminal Charges, Guilty Defendant, But a Surprising Result

    Shared by firm partner, Kenneth Rhoden, Esquire, a death penalty qualified criminal defense attorney, Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure 3.112. 

    *This story uses no names and some of the facts have been changed to protect the privacy of the participants.*

    The Defendant had a prior record and he scored mandatory prison under the Criminal Punishment Code’s scoresheet. The State Attorney, feeling justifiably confident in his case, offered only a stiff prison sentence as a plea bargain. Feeling the Defendant had nothing to lose I set this for trial.

    Sometimes officers are suddenly unavailable for trial and a case gets dismissed or evidence was lost or another unlikely event happens. In this case, the cocaine had been sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement Lab which confirmed it was indeed cocaine. The State Attorney smoothly introduced the cocaine into evidence over my repeated, but correctly overruled, objections. Then the two officers involved were called to testify.

    The first officer strutted into the courtroom with a smirk on his face. On direct examination, the officer was arrogant and all but rolled his eyes letting everyone know that this trial was a waste of his precious time. Despite this, the officer competently explained the events to the jury and there was no doubt the Defendant committed the crime. While the officer was disdainful of the State Attorney on direct examination, he was openly hostile to me on cross examination.  The second officer was equally disagreeable, but his testimony reinforced the first officer’s testimony.

    The officers testified they were on motorcycles when they spotted a car parked behind a closed business. They decided to check and see if any crime was taking place. The officers parked a distance behind the car and approached from behind, one officer on each side of the car, the suspect was engrossed in what he was doing and did not notice the officers approaching.

    The officers positioned themselves on each side of the car, looking in the windows. The officers could clearly see the suspect smoking crack cocaine from a pipe. After watching the suspect for a few minutes, the officers knocked on the side of the car. The startled suspect surrendered peacefully and admitted he had been smoking crack cocaine. The officers seized the crack cocaine and pipe and arrested the suspect for possession of cocaine and possession of paraphernalia.

    During cross examination the more unpleasant each officer became, the more polite was my demeanor.  The more questions I asked the more irritated each officer became as he/she testified.   They even showed their disdain for the Judge when she overruled the State Attorney’s objections to some of my questions. Despite my persistent questioning I was unable to cast serious doubt on the facts of the case.

    After short closing arguments by the State and Defense the jury left the courtroom to deliberate. I expected a quick guilty verdict. Sure enough in fifteen (15) minutes the jury had a verdict.   However, the verdict was Not Guilty.

    This event is commonly called a “jury pardon” and it is a rare event.  In this case the Defendant was very lucky. A trial is a complex event in which the unexpected can happen. This case shows you should never give up and when you have nothing to lose, always roll the dice.   The attorneys of Mario, Gunde, Peters, Rhoden & Kelley tried thousands of cases and will not hesitate to try your case if that gives you the best chance for a good outcome.

    Our firm celebrates 40 years serving this community in 2016.  We have more than seven attorneys available to assist you with your case.  And with this approach every client has the benefit of all the years and types of experience of our attorneys.  Initial consultations are always free and you can reach an attorney 24//7 for your urgent needs by calling the office at 321-631-0506 or email the office using the contact form at the top of this page.

    Related Topics

    1. Criminal Appeal Attorney
    2. Bill Cosby Should Have Called Brevard County’s Largest Criminal Defense and Family Law Firm
    3. Criminal Law
    4. Juvenile Trials
    5. Appeals
    6. Felony Homicide in Florida
    7. How to Avoid Arrest for Drug Crimes
    8. Probation & Community Control
    9. Markeith Loyd Case and State Attorney Aramis Ayala
    10. If You Are Charged With a Crime You Need a Great Criminal Defense Attorney

    Email Us

      Disclaimer • © 2021 Mario Gunde Peters Rhoden & Kelley (Legal Eagles) • Powered by Geek Fu
      Disclaimer

      The information on this website is not legal advice and is provided only as general information. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. The law changes rapidly and can be interpreted in different ways by different courts. The contents of this site could be unsuitable to your circumstances, outdated, or not sufficiently detailed for your needs. An attorney-client relationship is not created by review of this site. By use of this site, as with any electronic communications privacy is not guaranteed. Mario, Gunde, Peters, Rhoden & Kelley will not sell or disclose or in anyway use information you provide that is not consistent with the provision of legal services, unless required by law. This website is provided without warranty either express or implied of any kind. Links within this website are independent of this website and are provided only as a convenience and MGPR&K disclaims any responsibility for the contents of the sites.